|q⟩ Bad Qubits

intermediate · Physics · Identical Particles & Exchange Symmetry

Bose–Einstein and Fermi–Dirac Statistics

At finite temperature a gas of identical particles distributes itself across energy levels. The exchange symmetry that classified particles into bosons and fermions also dictates how many of them can sit in each level, and that gives two distinct statistical laws — completely different from the classical Maxwell–Boltzmann result.

Counting states correctly

In classical statistics, particles are distinguishable, so swapping two of them between levels counts as a new arrangement. For identical quantum particles it does not: the same set of occupation numbers is one and only one state. Bosons and fermions then differ in which occupation numbers are allowed:

These two counting rules, fed through the grand-canonical ensemble, produce the two famous distributions.

The two distributions

The average occupation of a single-particle level of energy ε\varepsilon, at temperature TT and chemical potential μ\mu, is

nˉBE(ε)=1e(εμ)/kBT1(Bose–Einstein),\bar{n}_\text{BE}(\varepsilon) = \frac{1}{e^{(\varepsilon - \mu)/k_B T} - 1} \qquad\text{(Bose–Einstein)}, nˉFD(ε)=1e(εμ)/kBT+1(Fermi–Dirac).\bar{n}_\text{FD}(\varepsilon) = \frac{1}{e^{(\varepsilon - \mu)/k_B T} + 1} \qquad\text{(Fermi–Dirac)}.

The only difference is the sign in the denominator: 1-1 for bosons, +1+1 for fermions. In the limit e(εμ)/kBT1e^{(\varepsilon-\mu)/k_B T} \gg 1 (high temperature or low density), both reduce to the classical Maxwell–Boltzmann form nˉe(εμ)/kBT\bar{n} \approx e^{-(\varepsilon-\mu)/k_B T}, where quantum statistics become irrelevant because occupations are tiny.

Reading the physics off the sign

The +1+1 in Fermi–Dirac guarantees nˉFD1\bar{n}_\text{FD} \le 1 for all energies — the Pauli principle written into thermodynamics. As T0T \to 0, every level below μ\mu (the Fermi energy EFE_F) is filled exactly once and every level above is empty: a sharp Fermi sea. This is why metals conduct, why electrons in a white dwarf resist compression, and why the heat capacity of a metal's electrons is small.

The 1-1 in Bose–Einstein allows nˉBE\bar{n}_\text{BE} to grow without bound as εμ\varepsilon \to \mu. Cool a boson gas enough and a macroscopic fraction of the particles crashes into the single lowest state — Bose–Einstein condensation, first achieved with dilute atomic gases in 1995 and visible in superfluidity and lasing.

A small example

Two identical particles, two levels of energies 00 and ε\varepsilon. Count the distinct two-particle states:

The same two levels host different numbers of states depending on the statistics, which is exactly why the thermal averages differ.

The takeaway

Exchange symmetry, not any new force, gives identical particles their thermal behaviour: fermions obey Fermi–Dirac statistics and fill states one at a time up to the Fermi energy, while bosons obey Bose–Einstein statistics and can pile into a single state. Both collapse to the classical Maxwell–Boltzmann law when occupations are sparse. These distributions underpin solid-state physics, astrophysics, and the entire field of ultracold atoms.

Sign in on the full site to ask questions and join the discussion.